As we approach the deadline, the whole MLB world waits for the Baltimore Orioles to trade superstar shortstop Manny Machado. What team would be the best fit for him though? In this article, we’ll examine how Machado fits with each team that has been rumored to be interested in acquiring him by looking at potential lineups with him in it, as well as examining if acquiring him is the right move for the franchise.
Arizona Diamondbacks
Predicted Lineup:
Jon Jay RF
Paul Goldschmidt 1B
Manny Machado SS
Jake Lamb 3B
AJ Pollock CF
David Peralta LF
Daniel Descalso 2B
John Ryan Murphy C
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup:
Jon Jay RF
AJ Pollock CF
Manny Machado SS
Paul Goldschmidt 1B
Jake Lamb 3B
David Peralta LF
John Ryan Murphy C
Daniel Descalso 2B
Pitcher
How he fits: The Diamondbacks have gotten limited production from their middle infield, and seem to be missing some firepower in their lineup. Machado would fix both of these problems, as he’d give Arizona the second star they’ve been for to compliment Paul Goldschmidt. They became one of baseball’s elite teams last year when they traded for JD Martinez last year, and I’d expect an even bigger jump this if they acquired a more all around star in Machado. It’s a perfect fit, as Machado (.311/.378/.565) would step in as a major upgrade over Nick Ahmed (.223/.282/.412) offensively. Defensively, it’s a major downgrade by the metrics (-29 drs), but Machado’s WAR (1.8) is still higher than Ahmed’s (1.4), and isn’t as bad of a defender as the metrics say.
Fit: 9.5/10
Need: 10/10
Los Angeles Dodgers
Predicted Lineup:
Joc Pederson LF
Max Muncy 2B
Manny Machado SS
Justin Turner 3B
Cody Bellinger 1B
Matt Kemp RF
Yasmani Grandal C
Chris Taylor CF
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup:
Chris Taylor CF
Manny Machado SS
Justin Turner 3B
Cody Bellinger 1B
Matt Kemp RF
Max Muncy 2B
Yasmani Grandal C
Joc Pederson LF
Pitcher
How he fits: Machado’s fit in LA isn’t ideal. With the lineup as it is currently, the Dodgers already are having trouble giving everyone playing time. With both Chris Taylor and Enrique Hernandez doing well at short, it doesn’t seem as Machado will make as much of a difference with the Dodgers as he would with different teams. If they decide to move Taylor or Hernandez to the outfield, then that will only take away playing time from Joc Pederson and Matt Kemp, arguably their two most productive players outside of Max Muncy, who’s playing time would also be in jeopardy if they try to move Taylor or Hernandez to second. The Dodgers would be much better off adding to their bullpen than going all in for a superstar in Machado.
Fit: 3/10
Need: 5/10
Philadelphia Phillies
Predicted Lineup
Cesar Hernandez 2B
Odubel Herrera CF
Manny Machado SS
Rhys Hoskins LF
Carlos Santana 1B
Nick Williams RF
Jorge Alfaro C
Maikel Franco 3B
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup
Cesar Hernandez 2B
Odubel Herrera CF
Manny Machado SS
Rhys Hoskins LF
Carlos Santana 1B
Nick Williams RF
Maikel Franco 3B
Jorge Alfaro C
Pitcher
How he fits: Machado’s a good fit for the Phillies at shortstop, but he’s an even better one at third base. That’s because the Phillies have two young middle infielders in Scott Kingery and JP Crawford, so having Machado play short would give them less playing time and therefore would hurt their development. If Machado were to play third base however, he’d be a major upgrade offensively and defensively over Maikel Franco, who has regressed from his amazing rookie season. It’s unlikely that Machado moves back to third, but if he did, he would be an excellent fit in Philadelphia. Even if he stays at short, he makes the Phillies among the NL’s best teams if not the best.
Fit: 8.5/10
Need: 8.5/10
Chicago Cubs
Predicted Lineup
Albert Almora CF
Manny Machado SS
Anthony Rizzo 1B
Kris Bryant 3B
Javier Baez 2B
Kyle Schwarber LF
Willson Contreras C
Jayson Heyward RF
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup
Javier Baez 2B
Manny Machado SS
Anthony Rizzo 1B
Kris Bryant 3B
Wilson Contreras C
Kyle Schwarber LF
Albert Almora CF
Pitcher
Jayson Heyward RF
How he fits: For some reason, many people have questioned Manny Machado’s fit with the Cubs. In reality though, Machado would turn the Cubs into a super team. A 2-3-4 of Machado, Anthony Rizzo, and Kris Bryant would be unstoppable. With all of them in the lineup, pitchers wouldn’t be able to work around them, and therefore all of them would see their production increase. Machado seems to be a downgrade defensively to Addison Russell, but by the eye test the average MLB fan can see that Machado may actually be an upgrade. The Cubs are in a position where they are well-rounded, but not good enough to win the world series. Adding Machado would make them the best team in baseball.
Fit: 9.5/10
Need: 8.5/10
Cleveland Indians
Predicted Lineup
Francisco Lindor SS
Manny Machado 3B
Jose Ramirez 2B
Edwin Encarnacion DH
Michael Brantley LF
Yonder Alonso 1B
Yan Gomes C
Lonnie Chisenhall RF
Tyler Naquin CF
Suggested Lineup
Francisco Lindor SS
Michael Brantley LF
Manny Machado 3B
Jose Ramirez 2B
Edwin Encarnacion DH
Yonder Alonso 1B
Lonnie Chisenhall RF
Yan Gomes C
Tyler Naquin CF
How he fits: The are a lot of moving parts in fitting Machado into the Indians lineup. First off, Machado would have to agree to go back to third, as Francisco Lindor is a much better defensive option at short stop. Then, the Indians would have to move Jose Ramirez from third base to second. So basically its swapping out Jason Kipnis, who is currently hitting .214/.293/.338 with a 0.1 WAR for Machado, who by contrast is hitting .311/.378.565 with a 1.8 WAR. The Indians currently have one of the best rotations in baseball, and a bullpen that still has Andrew Miller and Cody Allen. While they don’t have any sort of depth in their bullpen, it can be argued that upgrading offensively should be a much bigger priority for Cleveland. For a team that relies so heavily on switch hitters and lefties, adding a right-handed superstar in Machado makes perfect sense, and would give them arguably the best top of the lineup in baseball.
Fit: 9/10
Need: 10/10
St.Louis Cardinals
Predicted Lineup:
Matt Carpenter 3B
Tommy Pham CF
Manny Machado SS
Jose Martinez 1B
Marcell Ozuna LF
Yadier Molina C
Jedd Gyroko 2B
Harrison Bader RF
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup
Tommy Pham CF
Manny Machado SS
Matt Carpenter 3B
Marcell Ozuna LF
Jose Martinez 1B
Jedd Gyroko 2B
Yadier Molina C
Pitcher
Harrison Bader RF
How he fits: The Cardinals are starting to fall out of the playoff race, as they are 43-41 currently. However, still expect them to be desperate and aggressive at the trade deadline as they look to avoid missing the playoffs for a third straight season. With shortstop Paul DeJong hurt, the Cardinals have needs at every infield position. The most ideal thing would be to have Machado play short and then move him to third and Matt Carpenter to second base when DeJong comes back. As for the need, the Cardinals need a difference maker like Machado badly. Unlike other clubs in this list, the Cardinals are a star away from just making the postseason, as their lineup has been awful with Dexter Fowler and Tommy Pham failing to produce. Adding Machado into their lineup may just be the spark plug they need to get their offense going. The question though, will it be too late by the time they trade for him?
Fit: 8.5/10
Need: 8.5/10
Milwaukee Brewers
Predicted Lineup:
Lorenzo Cain CF
Christian Yelich RF
Manny Machado SS
Jesus Aguilar 1B
Travis Shaw 3B
Ryan Braun LF
Jonathan Villar 2B
Manny Pina C
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup
Lorenzo Cain CF
Christian Yelich RF
Manny Machado SS
Jesus Aguilar 1B
Travis Shaw 3B
Ryan Bruan LF
Manny Pina C
Pitcher
Jonathan Villar 2B
How he fits: This is a long shot from happening, but it makes a lot of sense. Coming into the season, the Brewers were hoping that prospect Orlando Arcia would be the team’s long-term shortstop. However, he’s struggled so badly that he’s been sent to Triple-A and the team even drafted a shortstop in the first round. Now, Arcia still may be the team’s shortstop long term, but he’s likely not going to be a factor for the rest of the year. Getting Machado for the remainder of this season makes a lot of sense, as he’s surely a major upgrade over Brad Miller, the team’s current starting shortstop. The only issue with a possible Machado trade is the team’s need for an ace is much greater than its need for another star offensive player. The Brewers should look at getting Chris Archer or Jacob deGrom first. If they fail to acquire one of those two though, Machado is an excellent plan B.
Fit: 9.5/10
Need: 8/10
Atlanta Braves
Predicted Lineup
Ender Inciarte CF
Ozzie Albies 2B
Manny Machado 3B
Freddie Freeman 1B
Nick Markakis RF
Ronald Acuna LF
Tyler Flowers C
Dansby Swanson SS
Pitcher
Suggested Lineup:
Ozzie Albies 2B
Manny Machado 3B
Freddie Freeman 1B
Ronald Acuna LF
Nick Markakis RF
Dansby Swanson SS
Tyler Flowers C
Pitcher
Ender Inciarte CF
How he fits: This is another case where Machado would have to move to third base. Dansby Swanson is the team’s long-term shortstop, and his 10 drs show he’s one of the game’s best defensive shortstops. With top prospect Austin Riley set as Atlanta’s long-term third baseman, Machado wouldn’t be in Atlanta for any longer than the rest of the season. He’d make a big difference though, as he’s a major upgrade over Johan Camargo at third base. Atlanta needs two things: a better bullpen and a better third baseman. The bullpen should be more of a concern over third base, as they don’t have any reliable options outside of Arodys Vizcaino. However, there are a lot of cheap veteran options that won’t hurt Atlanta’s deep farm system. This deep farm system includes a lot of pitching depth, so they probably have the easiest path to acquiring Machado. If they’re serious about winning the World Series, then they should go out and acquire him, as that would make them the World Series favorite.
Fit: 7.5/10
Need: 8.5/10
While many of the teams listed here should trade for Machado, the two best fits for him are the Diamondbacks and Indians. He’d turn both of these teams into World Series contenders and is worth the risk. As long as he’d be open to moving back to third base, I think Cleveland has more talent around him and a more clear need for him. If he’s persistent a playing shortstop, Arizona is also an extraordinary fit that needs another star next to Paul Goldschmidt and would become the NL’s best team.
It’s not every day that a player of Manny Machado’s caliber becomes available on the trade market. Teams that need him need to take advantage of this opportunity, and acquire him. We’ve seen so many trade deadline acquisitions, such as Justin Verlander and Hunter Pence, be the difference between winning the World Series and not making it. Therefore, teams serious on winning the World Series this year need to trade for him.
